Beyond English Channel Tragedy!



by Nilofar Suhrawardy

Death of migrants in the English Channel has hit headlines as “worst disaster on record” with France and United Kingdom’s “war of words” marking a “low point” in their ties, a “humanitarian crisis” and so forth. Who is to be blamed for this tragedy? Little importance has been given to the hard reality that the increase in migrants being desperate for better opportunities may not have reached this level if most countries had not been struck by the Arab Winter. Yes, this draws attention to their being targeted by external powers- in the name of Arab Spring – trying to impose so-called democracy in their homelands. Virtually dead silence of major powers to what Arab Winter has spelt for affected people can hardly be ignored. In fact, English Channel tragedy cannot be viewed as simply one for which either UK, France or both are to be blamed. Some importance also needs to be given to reasons responsible for “migrants” being desperate to move from beyond their borders.

What is also stunning is that the religious identity of migrants has been virtually ignored. Perhaps. Paradoxically, religious identity is largely sidelined when they tend to be victims but is highlighted if some of them are viewed as criminals and are instantly labeled. This also draws attention to the marked absence of voice regarding Channel tragedy.

Practically speaking, given the diversity – regional and cultural – among Muslims spread across the world, the question of there being any one voice representing them all may be viewed as non-existent. Nevertheless, that concerned non-Muslims as well as Muslims have not refrained from voicing their grievances.


Also Read : Scams exploded during ten years of UPA rule: PM Modi


Undeniably, the communication boom has enhanced importance as well as reach of media, making the world a smaller place at this level. The irony of this reality lies in it being applicable practically in most parts of the world. What is communicated in XYZ country can bear significance in other countries for humanitarian, religious, economic as well as several other reasons. The recent episode of the princess not chosen to express her reservations against an anchor being invited to UAE for the international conference backed by specific reasons, in all probability, the anchor’s “communal” vibes would have not hit headlines in international circles. Yes, irrespective of various other communal issues have been paid similar attention or not, raising a voice against the anchor has most probably raised quite a few eye-brows among those given to indulge in similar practices. In fact, this aspect should be given substantial importance by not such Islamic states but also by democratic, secular countries in lieu of their socio-politico values as well as humanitarian concerns.

Each religion in essence gives utmost importance to humane values. Propagating either communalism and/or terrorism is hardly in line with basic principles of any religion. This draws attention to stereotyped notions still prevalent easily linking Islam, Hinduism and Sikhism with terrorism. This scribe has frequently questioned this tendency. On one side, those indulging in aggressive violence try and justify their activities by adding “religious” label to it. The tragedy is “criminals” attempting this are easily believed and their “justification” is held as “genuine”. At the same time, the prevalent tendency to easily link religious practiced by an alleged criminal with terrorism particularly in the West cannot be ignored. If the accused person is a Muslim, Sikh, Hindu, a Brown or Black, his/her religion/race is instantly labeled as terrorist. It is this tendency that has over decades led to misconceptions such as Islamic terrorism, Hindu terrorism and so forth.

True, now and then incidents of communal violence keep surfacing. But what is indulged in by a few should not be viewed as representative of communal behavior of their entire religious community. If this was the case, we would not have been home to the second largest population of Muslims in the world. Against this backdrop, the UAE princess raised her voice. One, given the negative notions easily linked with Islam, these should certainly be questioned. At the same time, no religion or religious community has been viewed along negative lines. Besides, English Channel tragedy demands deliberation from this angle also! (

Nilofar Suhrawardy is a senior journalist and writer with specialization in communication studies and nuclear diplomacy.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.


You may like

Hot Videos
In the news